自由講場 今日: 3325 | 主題: 1304348

積分: 10230

1^#

發表於 09-4-5 22:48 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印

As a matter of fact, he is talking reality.
Just one question,
ask most of the phillipinos ,What is your job ?

I just understand that hk people are not happy that we no longer happy to go to victoria park at weekends.
A community can share differnt voices, and for his point of views he does apology already for publicity, but l feel that he is telling the truth.

This is not races or bias,...we need to be treat in fair too.
Indeed ,so many south asian use hk refugge laws to stay in hk and share the tax funds that we pay for!

0 0 0

私人傳訊

積分: 151977

2^#

發表於 09-4-6 00:24 |只看該作者

我睇完陶傑篇文章，都覺得有踩人之嫌，呢個一向係陶傑既風格，但係香港人接受左，唔代表其他國家既人可以接受到，每人每國都有底線，好似你唔可以摸泰國人既頭一樣，對於佢地係禁忌，代表唔尊重，係冒犯行為，中國人當然唔覺得有問題啦，但如果身為中國人，偏要對一個泰國人咁做，咁又係咩行為呢?

有時要有同理心，唔好下下覺得自己都冇惡意，縮下膊頭講一句玩下啫咁就得架，稱呼人地為「僕人之國」，而大家都明白僕人地位較低，又確實係有扁意喎。

佢寫中文咪好囉，以陶傑支筆咁辛辣，可能唔會攪到依家咁大鑊啦!

原帖由 vesley 於 09-4-5 22:48 發表
As a matter of fact, he is talking reality.
Just one question,
ask most of the phillipinos ,What is your job ?

I just understand that hk people are not happy that we no longer happy to go to victori ...

私人傳訊

積分: 10230

3^#

發表於 09-4-6 21:45 |只看該作者

回覆 # 的文章

有時要有同理心，唔好下下覺得自己都冇惡意，....
Yes. But l still think he is talking reality.
As a matter of fact, he is talking the truth.
Just one question,
ask most of the phillipinos ,What is your job ? They should be proud of their jobs as maid. One day ,if they want hire Chinese to work for them? I guess , a lot of mainland WANTS THE JOB TOO. we have cheap labour too.

私人傳訊

積分: 151977

4^#

發表於 09-4-6 23:00 |只看該作者

係既，公務員都稱為"civil servant"引伸為"public servant"(公僕)，servant實際指忠良服務者，可能菲律賓人眼見香港公務員地位咁卑微，俾人拎蕉、講粗口。"servant"呢個字眼出自一個香港人既手，佢地當然以為指地位不被尊重既人，仲要"a nation of servants"，仲得了!全國人等同香港既公僕，地位等如奴隸一般，所以先會咁反感，又好難怪菲律賓人對"servant"呢個字咁敏感喎，有版佢地睇吖嘛!

原帖由 vesley 於 09-4-6 21:45 發表
有時要有同理心，唔好下下覺得自己都冇惡意，....
Yes. But l still think he is talking reality.
As a matter of fact, he is talking the truth.
Just one question,
ask most of the phillipinos ,What is your job ...

私人傳訊

chanwendy

伯爵府

積分: 16903

5^#

發表於 09-4-7 10:00 |只看該作者

幾年前唔記得係 tvb 定係港台都做過一個特輯係講菲律賓人在港受到歧視的情況, 原來香港有唔少菲律賓人唔係做菲傭架, 佢地有啲仲係大學教授, 公司老闆添呀. 我個人就覺得亞才子點都係錯架喇, 佢既然咁有文采, 唔應該咁樣遣詞囉, 有時唔係話 "telling the truth" 就可以講啲傷害人心的說話. 如果唔係, 點解所有中國人都對 "東亞病夫" 呢四個字咁反感先, 某程度上當時的日本人正正就係 "telling the truth".

私人傳訊

積分: 10230

6^#

發表於 09-4-8 00:43 |只看該作者

回覆 # 的文章

bUT MOST 香港菲律賓人係做菲傭架,
THERE IS SOME 大學教授, 公司老闆添呀.

有時唔係話 "telling the truth" 就可以講啲傷害人心的說話.
IN FACT , THEY WERE PAID TO BE A MAID.
AND PHILLIPINOS DOES EXPORT SERVANTS AS COUNTRY BUSINESS.

HOWEVER, 點解所有中國人都對 "東亞病夫" 呢四個字咁反感先,
BECAUSE THEY WERE POISON TO BE "東亞病夫" , THEY WERE BUYING DRUGS TO BECAME "東亞病夫" .
NOWADAYS, IT IS LIKE E -PILLS.
IT IS NOT A JOB FOR EXPORT. IT IS A CRIME.

CIVIL SERVANTS IS SERVANTS TO THE PUBLIC , I AGREE. BUT , I THINK THEY HAVE TO SERVE THE PUBLIC MORE MORALLY BECAUSE FROM TODAY NEWS ,
THEY WERE INVOLVE SO MUCH ON FINACIAL PROBLEMS.

THE CRIMINAL MAKING THE TRUTH,某程度上當時的日本人正正就係 "telling the truth" . AS TO KILL CHINA WHEN WEAK.

IT IS OUR LUCK THAT CHINA HAVE BECAME STRONG NOW, SO WE ARE NO LONGER "東亞病夫" AND EVEN THESE DAYS IN FOREIGN COUNTRY, CHINESE ARE NO LONGER CHINESE WOK AND LAUNDRY MAN. A LOT OF THEM WERE
大學教授 AND VERY IMPORTANT PERSON IN THE NATIONS.

SO, INSTEAD OF BBB ,WHY DON'T THEY CHANGE THEIR SECOND GENERATION TO BECAME HIGHER IN THE JOB NATURE .THEN, THEY CAN HIRE CHINAMAN TO BECOME THEIR SERVANT OF NATION , IF THEY COULD...

[ 本帖最後由 vesley 於 09-4-8 01:02 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

yennie

男爵府

積分: 7031

好媽媽勳章畀面勳章

7^#

發表於 09-4-8 01:06 |只看該作者

如果香港無菲傭，好多父母跟本就出唔到嚟做野
我地靠佢地幫我地喺屋企做家務，湊小朋友，我地先可以出嚟搵錢
佢地都係為咗自己屋企人喺菲律賓生活好d啫...我地相方都係互惠互利啫...唔好攪到陶傑咁歧視好喎...
佢地離鄉別井，唔可以好似我地咁netmeeting, 打下電話搵親人。有時唔開心又要等到星期日先有人同佢地傾下咁
其實佢地真係好慘㗎...

話時話
廸廸尼嘅跳舞演藝人員，好多都係菲律賓嚟㗎!佢地跳得好好㗎！

私人傳訊

積分: 10230

8^#

發表於 09-4-8 19:35 |只看該作者

回覆 # 的文章

Yes. better be honour to their job.

私人傳訊

積分: 151977

9^#

發表於 09-4-8 23:29 |只看該作者

唔係好明呢一句，「東亞病夫」係當年清朝積弱，俾八國聯軍入侵，又冇理地要求賠償好多錢，並且土地被割據為殖民地，於是歐洲以至日本稱中國為「東亞病夫」，而唔係吸毒喎，真抓頭

係佢呢一篇文章，起初以日本、蘇聯係中國友好為文首，寫兩國文化感染及影響香港及中國，而菲律賓就唔同，佢地有13名傭工在港工作，國內宣佈南沙群島有主權，就係大逆不道，對主人露肌肉。

菲律賓有人口大約9千幾萬人，當中有大約1千萬係華人外，咁都仲有8千萬，得13萬人在香港工作，即係每月賺取約4千6百幾萬港幣，俱俱果數千萬一個月，就可以頂起整個國家9千幾萬人既經濟咩?係香港傭工數目只佔佢地整國0.0014%人口，阿陶生是否有如佢崇拜既洋人一樣咁白鴿眼及自大呢下?

陶生一向都崇洋，唔明點解會忽然愛國，維護起南沙群島主權黎，可能佢敬愛既偶像英美因金融海嘯被淹至差點沒頂，於是學人寫下愛國文章，但可惜畫虎不成反為犬(希望你睇得明呢句既意思，我唔係講緊畫畫之道

)，因為實在不慣愛國，於是扭扭捏捏，擦中國鞋又不似擦中國，但卻擦出歧視菲國言論，一觸即發，此星火有機會燎原。

如果因為陶生一篇「真言」文章，令我家菲傭被召回國，我諗我都要搵陶生負責任，還我家傭

，或者由佢黎補償我因沒有家傭而要炒老細尤魚番歸做替工既月薪。

原帖由 vesley 於 09-4-8 00:43 發表
bUT MOST 香港菲律賓人係做菲傭架,
THERE IS SOME 大學教授, 公司老闆添呀.

有時唔係話 "telling the truth" 就可以講啲傷害人心的說話.
IN FACT , THEY WERE PAID TO BE A MAID.
AND PHILLIPINOS DOES EXPORT S ...........

HOWEVER, 點解所有中國人都對 "東亞病夫" 呢四個字咁反感先,
BECAUSE THEY WERE POISON TO BE "東亞病夫" , THEY WERE BUYING DRUGS TO BECAME "東亞病夫" .
NOWADAYS, IT IS LIKE E -PILLS.
IT IS NOT A JOB FOR EXPORT. IT IS A CRIME.

[ 本帖最後由 SandyKL 於 09-4-8 23:35 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

yennie

男爵府

積分: 7031

好媽媽勳章畀面勳章

10^#

發表於 09-4-8 23:48 |只看該作者

原帖由 SandyKL 於 09-4-8 23:29 發表
唔係好明呢一句，「東亞病夫」係當年清朝積弱，俾八國聯軍入侵，又冇理地要求賠償好多錢，並且土地被割據為殖民地，於是歐洲以至日本稱中國為「東亞病夫」，而唔係吸毒喎，真抓頭

係佢呢一篇文章，起初以日本、蘇聯係中 ...

well said!

私人傳訊

積分: 151977

11^#

發表於 09-4-9 01:09 |只看該作者

Thank you!I am telling the truth.

原帖由 yennie 於 09-4-8 23:48 發表

well said!

私人傳訊

牛精仔